Health – Page 4 – justanoldcountrydoctor

Dear Minister Jones – Fire Your Negotiations Team.

Dear Minister Jones,

Just me again, a certain crotchety and increasingly cantankerous geezer offering you advice in an open letter that you are not likely to take. But you would be better off if you did. More importantly, so would the people of Ontario.

First, I would once again suggest that you have done some good work in the health ministry. Moving surgical procedures to outpatient clinics, increasing the number of diagnostic testing facilities, starting a new medical school focused on training family doctors and more are all good moves. While the effects of some of those decisions will not be felt for many years – the reality is that somebody had to do this to help health care down the road and you’ve done that.

Unfortunately however, the past couple of weeks have been catastrophic for your Ministry’s relationship with Ontario’s doctors. It’s funny how one dumb decision or comment can completely wreck a relationship, but that’s exactly what happened when your Negotiations Team stated that there was “no concern” about a diminished supply of doctors. Therefore, they refused to negotiate money for retention of physicians or admin work, like other provinces have (cough BC, cough Manitoba, cough EVEN Alberta!)

In essence, your Negotiations Team has been a disaster, first by militantly dragging out negotiations into a very adversarial arbitration process (when all the other provinces above figured out a way to, you know, respectfully negotiate with doctors) – and then by making a statement about the supply of doctors that is so comically stupid and out of touch that Ontario has become a laughing stock.

Three members of the Ministry’s Negotiations Team pictured above.

This will not bode well for health care in this province.

Look, I know there may be a temptation to say “Ok this was a mistake” and to try and walk back the comments.. While it’s abundantly true that the people of Ontario are a good and kind people who will forgive politicians if they own up to their mistakes (cough greenbelt, cough enhanced police powers and closing playgrounds during covid) – one thing that politicians can’t survive, is being made a laughing stock. Except Donald Trump of course. I still haven’t figured that one out and I don’t think I ever will. (N.B. Donald Trump is not someone you should try to emulate).

Anyway, the reality is that at this point you really only have one path left to turn this thing around. You have to fire your negotiations team. All of them. I’m not just talking about the seven who were appointed to lead that team, I’m talking about the multiple bureaucrats who give them supporting data and have influenced their position.

The only rational explanation I can think of for those bureaucrats promoting a position of “no concern” about physician supply, and saying doctors are not working hard enough, is that they hate doctors. Many of them were likely hired at a time when it was fashionable to bash doctors for billing “too much”. (BTW how did that attitude work out for the people of Ontario?) They’ve clearly carried on with that belief in the arbitration proposals.

I get that in arbitration, there will be some posturing. If your Negotiations Team had said “we’ll pay you $50 a month as a retention bonus” or “admin work doesn’t involve seeing patients, so we’ll pay you $20 an hour” – I honestly would have shrugged my shoulders, recognized it was part of the arbitration “game” and said nothing.

But to say retention and recruitment of physicians is not a major concern, when people line up for hours on end just for the faint chance of getting a family doctor?? That thought process can only be due to a pathologic hatred of physicians, or a delusional mindset totally divorced from reality. Either is a cause for termination. Can the whole team now.

A long line forms outside CDK Family Medicine and Walk-In Clinic in Kingston, Ont.. It was the first day of ‘rostering’ at the clinic, where four doctors will take as many as 4,000 new patients. (Jamie Corbett) – from CBC News

But what of negotiations with the OMA you may ask?

Actually, that’s not hard either. Your ministry has an appointee to the Arbitration Board, just like the OMA does. I believe your appointee is one Kevin Smith. The job of the appointee is to tell you and your team what the lead arbitrator, William Kaplan is thinking and how he is leaning. How they do that is beyond me. When I met Kaplan it was like talking to a Vulcan. There was absolutely no emotion or hint of what he was thinking – but apparently Kevin Smith is better than I am at figuring this out.

One of the above is William Kaplan, Arbitrator, and even after meeting him I’m not sure which is which.

What your appointee will tell you, and what the OMA appointee to the Board will tell the OMA is – Kaplan is wondering “this” or thinking “that” or leaning towards “X percent”. Find out what that X per cent is, offer it to the Doctors for the first year of the new Physicians Services Agreement (PSA). That solves things for one year, which gives you time to pick a brand new negotiations team for year 2-4 for the PSA.

Note to my three loyal readers, yes, this arbitration is ONLY for the percentage increase of the first year of the four year agreement. Worse, while the OMA and Ministry have generally agreed to a 70/30 split of whatever the amount is with 70% allotted to raises, and 30% to be given to targeted programs, they haven’t been able to agree on how the 30% is to be targeted. This means…..more arbitration for that piece. Then, it begins again next year for years 2-4 of the PSA. In essence, we appear to be locked in a perpetual, never ending antagonistic arbitration process (which is still better than unilateral government actions but really frustrating nonetheless).

As I told Premier Ford recently- if health care doesn’t get fixed – I don’t care what the polls say now, or how many by-elections you seem to have won, this is going to be a real problem in 2026. With health care in the crisis it is in now, you need all hands working together and co-operatively. Locking Ontario’s doctors into two more years of extremely adversarial arbitration shows that we are not co-operating and not working together. This is why graduates are leaving the province. And we can’t afford that.

It’s time for you to do the right thing for Ontario, and cut bait with your current negotiations team.

Yours sincerely,

An Old Country Doctor.

Perspectives on Ontario Health Care by a Recent Graduate

NB: My thanks to Dr. Tristan Brownrigg for guest blogging for me today. By his own admission, he never planned to be political, or seek out the limelight. But the situation in Ontario is such that he felt his perspective should be heard. I have a great deal of respect for people like Dr. Brownrigg, who are willing to step out of their comfort zone when necessary, and I commend him for doing so.

Dr. Tristan Brownrigg: I am a family physician, outdoorsman, and rural generalist currently working a mix of clinic, ER and inpatient care in the East Kootenays of British Columbia. I graduated from the University of Toronto Medical School, and did my Residency at Queen’s University (Kawartha site).

I completed family medicine residency in Ontario in 2022 and worked there for 6 months. Prior to this I completed medical school in Ontario, completed my undergraduate in Ontario, and had called Ontario home. Over the years I had watched my goal of working as a comprehensive rural family physician slowly become unsustainable amidst a collapsing system, decades of funding stagnation and poor planning, with a patchwork of good people on the ground trying to do their best in a system that doesn’t seem to value their input. Day after day the insidious march of the family medicine crisis grew closer to the forefront of peoples’ lives and garnered wider media attention, while the government either denied its existence or made no substantive changes that would realistically address it. This has not been the time for band-aids, let alone denial.

Last year I moved to rural British Columbia to try something different for a year, cautiously optimistic about the significant changes to family practice on the back of the LFP model implementation in early 2023. The Longitudinal Family Physician (LFP) model significantly changed how family physicians billed and were compensated in BC, including the ability to bill for the many hours family physicians typically spend on previously unpaid administrative tasks.

My experience has been night and day. For the first time in my medical career I have felt hopeful about the future of family medicine and find my day to day life to be sustainable. These changes have been received positively amongst all other family physicians I have discussed it with. It is not perfect and there are still kinks to be ironed out, but I at least believe my provincial medical association and government are trying to improve things for family physicians. I am not left questioning if government actions are purely incompetent or malicious with the intent to drive privatization.

I had retained my Ontario medical license until now, awaiting the May 2024 renewal deadline unsure if I would return home after a year of trying on a different life out west. Reading the recent government positions and negotiation briefs has been the final nail in the coffin for me. The disdain the Ontario government shows towards the hardworking family physicians who hold up the medical system is nothing short of repugnant. After more than a decade of training and education here, I will now be relinquishing my license to practice medicine in Ontario and stay in British Columbia.

The minister of health thinks recruitment and retention is “not a major concern.” That’s the problem; it should be. If I am not a prime example of this, I don’t know what is.

I wish all of my colleagues still in Ontario who do not have the luxury to vote with their feet the best of luck. If not this government, then I hope the next one learns to value your work and dedication.

Are You Accepting New Patients?

Dr. Madura Sundareswaran guest blogs for me today. She’s a community family physician who’s resume is too long to print here. She helped found the Peterborough Newcomer Health Clinic and is a recipient of the CPSO Board Award which recognizes outstanding Ontario Physicians. This article originally appeared on her LinkedIn page.

The day people stop asking this question is the day we have fixed the primary care crisis.

I’m a family physician doing community-based comprehensive family practice in Peterborough, Ontario. I currently work in three different primary care models in our community – fee-for-service, a team-based family health organization, and nurse-practitioner led clinics. All of my colleagues work very hard providing excellent care to their patients.

Despite this, the latest figures suggest that 32,000 people living in the Peterborough region do not have a family doctor.

What does that look like?

A woman in Peterborough notices a breast lump today and is very worried about it. She frantically searches google and reddit to learn that there are no walk-in clinics here. She calls a number late in the afternoon for a local clinic for unattached patients, but all the spots are full for the day. Her options are a virtual doctor who will never conduct a physical exam – but she thinks an exam is important – how will they ever know what this lump feels like virtually? She wants someone’s expertise, she wants reassurance. She decides to go to the emergency department for this problem…but leaves after waiting for 9 hours. She is guilt-ridden as she waits there – she is not as sick as the others in the waiting room. No physician or nurse practitioner will have enough of a relationship with this woman to know that she recently lost her best friend to breast cancer and the impact this has on her illness experience. She is freaking out about this lump…alone.

Or…

A 68 year old male has seen a few pharmacists and virtual family doctor for his hemorrhoids over the last year. He decides that he just has to live with hemorrhoids. A google search says his symptoms are classic for the problem; he’s reassured. As a doctor, I know that this gentleman needs a physical exam but this man cannot find someone to do it. After a few months he winds up in the emergency department with terrible pain – a physical exam very obviously demonstrates rectal cancer. It’s had a year to grow.

Or…

George is a 58 year old man who has never had a family doctor. He has been on Health Care Connect for four years but no one has ever called him to say they have found him a family doctor or nurse practitioner. He is in “perfect health” so he does not need a doctor. He has never had his blood pressure checked, never been counselled on smoking cessation, and has never had bloodwork done. What he doesn’t know is that his Hemoglobin A1c is 7.4 (he has Type II diabetes but too early for symptoms), he has hypertension (high blood pressure – which in its most common form has no symptoms or signs), and his cholesterol is really high. George will probably have a heart attack in the next 10 years. The potential consequences of a heart attack are death. This was entirely preventable.

What we know: attachment to a regular primary care provider (family physician or nurse practitioner) leads to more preventative care, better chronic disease management, and lower rates of hospital admission (ref)

We need a solution ASAP

I eagerly watched as Ontario announced $110 million that will “connect up to 328,000 people across Ontario to primary care teams.” For my community this also translated to a promise for a community health centre (CHC) to connect 11,375 people to primary care. This is much needed but not enough.

Ontario Health Minister Sylvia Jones announcing expansion of primary health care teams

In order to develop a community health centre – a building must be built or set up, policies will need to be implemented, and several primary care providers including physicians, nurse practitioners, social workers, pharmacists, dieticians, etc. will need to be hired. Even if this could be set up within 12 months, where does that leave the other 20,625 in the region without a family doctor? I’ll tell you – scrambling door to door and still knocking asking if anyone is accepting new patients.

But wait! There are other options. A single full-time family physician working in one of Peterborough’s existing family health organizations can roster approximately 1300 patients and join an existing team-based model. We currently have job openings in every one of our five existing multi-disciplinary teams for family physicians. A clinic could be up and running in a matter of weeks. There are family doctors in this community who are very eligible to take on this job – and would likely consider it if they were fairly and adequately compensated.

Learning from British Columbia

I am a firm believer in learning what works and never reinventing the wheel.

In 2023, British Columbia completely revamped its pay structure for family doctors. They paid their doctors better and restructured compensation models – and apparently within a year they got 700 more doing comprehensive, community-based family medicine.

Dr. Ramneek Dosanjh, Past President of Doctors of BC, who called the new funding formula for family physicians in BC a “seismic shift”

I am going to make a few assumptions but I want to illustrate and oversimplify something here.

In the new BC payment model, the pay per full time doctor increased by $135,000/year (assume per full time equivalent). It wasn’t just a pay raise – it involved a few critical changes regarding what doctors could bill for and some restructuring. But the end result was a pay raise.
This resulted in an increase of 700 family physicians (assume full time equivalent) practicing comprehensive family medicine over one year.
Let’s say 1 full time doctor rosters 1300 patients.
If Ontario could get 700 new full-time family doctors to provide comprehensive, community-based family medicine, 910,000 people could now have a family doctor.
The entire rollout for the BC program is budgeted at $708 million over three years but this would include complete restructuring from fee for service care. Ontario already invests over $1 billion annually in interdisciplinary primary care teams and we have a significant head start compared to BC a year ago.
In contrast, Ontario plans to spend an additional $110 million to connect up to 328,000 people across Ontario to primary care teams.

Providing family doctors with the financial support and resources to set up their own practices is the best bang-for-your-buck approach if the goal is patient attachment to a primary care provider.

We need an all hands on deck approach. Support community health centres, nurse practitioner led clinics, but please also support family physician’s practicing family medicine. That is the only way you will achieve attachment for all Ontarians.

Your most obvious solution is pay family physicians better today – so they will hold off retiring for a couple more years and may actually sign on to take a practice.

British Columbia just proved that fair and competitive compensation for family physicians may result in more of them doing it.

Why do I care?

I have been in family practice for five years. I have a roster of patients who have access to a whole range of team-based primary care services – a pharmacist, a social worker, a nurse practitioner, an RPN and multiple other service through our family health team. Every day I get asked if I can take on a friend or family member as they do not have or just lost their family doctor. This simple ask creates a great deal of stress and guilt for me. I know what happens when someone does not have a family doctor or nurse practitioner. They will be sicker, they may die sooner, they will be alone trying to “doctor” themselves.

The moral distress of being made to feel like I am determining people’s fate – giving some people a high standard of care while others are left to fend for themselves will be what ultimately leads to my exit from this profession in this province. Why do I get to give a small handful of people comprehensive team-based care, while the rest (often marginalized, more vulnerable patients) get nothing? It is not fair.

What next?

We are all eagerly awaiting the next negotiation between the Ontario Medical Association and the Ministry of Health.

If we do not see a pay raise for physicians, or worse, we pay them less – everyone in Ontario can accept the reality that they may have a lovely multidisciplinary medical home with a diverse range of primary care providers – but a family doctor probably will unlikely be part of it.

The next time a leader or politician is raving about their new model for care – or pitch a strategy that does not include a family doctor I urge every tax payer and journalist to ask them:

1. Do you have a publicly funded family doctor? (Do you truly understand what it means not to have one? Have you ever had to endure the struggle?)

2. If you are so confident in your plan, would you be willing to give up your family doctor to one of the 2.3 million people in Ontario without one?

3. Why is fair and competitive financial compensation of family physicians not part of your multi-pronged approach?

We are listening to politicians and leaders sell us on an idea of a fully-funded, glorious renovation. Meanwhile the house is on fire. Your family doctors are a dwindling number of people who cannot contain the flames. What are they worth?

Exploring Medical Tourism? Here’s What to Consider.

Full disclosure: I am a consultant for Medicte, a medical tourism firm that provides high quality, cost-effective medical treatments for ALL health conditions in Turkiye. Contact: info@medicte.ca for more information.

Recently, former Ontario Medical Association (OMA) President Dr. Shawn Whatley wrote an opinion piece in the National Post (later reproduced in the Medical Post) quite correctly rebuking Federal Health Minister Mark Holland for insulting people who consider leaving Canada for medically necessary health care. According to an Ipsos Reid poll, that’s 42 percent of all Canadians. As Dr. Whatley pointed out, this isn’t exactly a new phenomenon. In 2017, well before the Covid pandemic that people like to blame for just about everything, over 217,000 Canadians left the country for medical care. God only knows the 2023 number, but it will most certainly be higher.

Ironically enough, the day after Dr. Whatley’s piece was reproduced in the Medical Post, the Medical Post sent me their daily email which included a link to an article that showed Canadians are waiting even longer for surgical procedures than they were in 2019, and it’s not like the 2019 numbers were any good to begin with. It’s well known that increased wait times result in worsening morbidity and mortality (i.e. the longer you wait, the sicker you become). So it’s no wonder that Canadians are exploring ways to get treatments quickly, even if they have to pay out of pocket. Heck, I’m already on record as saying that I will go to Turkiye if Allah/God/Yahweh forbid I got a serious medical illness.

If you too are exploring medical tourism, here’s a list of things to consider.

How safe is the country I’m going to?

The sad reality is that the world has turned decidedly ugly these past few years. Picking a safe country can be hard. Stories like the one about Americans who went to Mexico for medical tourism and got shot by drug cartels get widely publicized. But there are many unsafe countries in the world. If I was looking at south of the United States, I’d probably limit my choices to Costa Rica and Cayman Islands. There are simply too many economic, political and frankly criminal elements in the rest of the countries south of the U.S.

Even in different continents you have to look at safety first. About 5 years ago a patient of mine of Ukrainian descent went back to Ukraine for a procedure. Obviously would not suggest that now with the war on. So look for somewhere stable.

What is the quality of the hospital I will get treatments at?

No hospital is perfect. But you should at least ensure that the hospital you are going to get care at is accredited by the Joint Commission International (JCI). They are the leading international organization that accredits hospitals and other health care organizations in 70 countries across the world. JCI Accreditation won’t guarantee a successful treatment, but it comes with the assurance that you will be getting appropriate health care.

After ensuring JCI accreditation at the facility you are looking at, then check for references. See if you can talk to people who got care there for their first hand experience.

Get a video consult first.

It’s the 21st century people. Video calls are a thing. If the health care organization you are looking doesn’t offer you the ability to have a video consultation with their doctors, before flying out to their country, well that’s a bad sign. During the consultation, ask lots of questions. Specifically ask about their complication rates and what is covered if you are unfortunate enough to get one. Get a “feel” for the doctor. It’s a big decision, be 100 per cent comfortable that the health care organization you are considering, will be able to take care of your needs.

What’s the Cost?

Obviously, at the end of the day, you are going to have to pay for your treatment. I would, of course, not suggest getting the cheapest possible treatment – because that institution has likely cut a lot of corners to get the price down. But at the same time, I weep for the lady from British Columbia, who, frustrated with the long wait times to see an oncologist, spent over $200,000 (US) on cancer care in the United States. She could have gotten the same treatments for around $70-80K in Turkiye. That’s obviously a lot of money, but still a significant savings.

This is actually why I would recommend you NOT go to the United States for medical tourism. Firstly, they have quite a bit of variability in terms of the care they provide. Some facilities are really good and others……well, some are really good. Secondly, the cost just isn’t worth it. A joint replacement that costs $50,000 US in the United States, could likely be had for $15-$20,000 US in another country.

If you are on a budget, or if you, like many others, are going to take out a loan or dip into your retirement savings to pay for these treatments, that difference is significant.

In Conclusion

While some provinces are making necessary investments in health care, the reality is that improvement in wait times are likely years away. The Canadian public is not stupid, they know this. Only 17% of Canadians feel the health system will improve in the near term.

In the interim, I fully expect the number of Canadian citizens who opt for medical tourism to increase. This can be a safe and effective option for Canadians willing to explore this route, but it is important to do your homework first.

Open Letter to Premier Ford: Fix Family Medicine or Risk Losing the Next Election

Dear Premier Ford,

Just me again, your erstwhile, somewhat (but not completely) humble old country doctor. Like last time, I would point out that I am really not your harshest critic. I want to recognize that you have done much for health care infrastructure over the past few years.

For reasons that I cannot fully explain, the previous Liberal regime simply stopped building the necessary infrastructure to help Ontarians. Whether it was new (badly needed) nursing homes, new hospitals, or new teams, the Liberals basically did, well, nothing in terms of infrastructure. To your credit, you’ve reversed that trend and are building facilities we in Ontario need. (As an aside, you seem to like building things a lot!)

But all of that building will not mean much in two years (when the next election is – nudge, nudge, wink, wink) if, as projected, over 25% of Ontarians don’t have a family doctor. Yes, you can correctly point out that the decline in family medicine was caused by the Liberals (it truly was – Eric Hoskins was by far the worst Health Minister I personally have seen in my time in health care). You can point out that the Liberals slashed the capitation model favoured by most family docs that started the downward trend. You can also point out that their favoured Deputy Health Minister Bob Bell thought family medicine was so easy he could return to it after over thirty years away:

He even tried to mansplain one of the true leaders of family medicine on how the system should work.

Thx Doc Silvy. I suggest that we need fundamental re-think of highly prevalent, poorly managed conditions. Agree that GP focused practices have cropped up in many of these areas, Sports, MH, PC, Chronic Pain- real issue is lack of programmatic care across province. 1/4 https://t.co/hblPVJqDzX
— Bob Bell (@drbobbell) January 27, 2019

It’s true Bell and Hoskins were completely wrong. That will NOT matter because by 2026, the general public will say – “well you’ve had 8 years to fix this – you haven’t done enough”. That’s just how politics is, and I think deep down you know that.

You can, truthfully, also say that you are listening to organizations like the Ontario College of Family Physicians or the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) and who continue to go on about how team based care is the future of family medicine and how it can help solve the problem. You may not know this but I was the founding Chair of the Georgian Bay Family Health Team . I happen to believe in physician led team based care.

But here’s the thing. It will take a minimum of five years (if we’re lucky) to build out all those teams. That’s assuming the bureaucrats from the Ministry GET OUT OF THE WAY and let front line family physicians be in charge of the teams. But we are losing family doctors by the week. The people of Ontario can’t wait five years.

There is one thing that can be done now however, to stem the tide, and stabilize the system. You need to give comprehensive care family physicians an immediate, and significant raise. How significant? You will need to give an immediate 35% increase to comprehensive care family docs along with annual normative increases for the next four years. If you think that’s outrageous – I invite you to look at Manitoba’s contract or Saskatchewan’s or British Columbia’s. The competition for comprehensive care family doctors has increased significantly, and Ontario is falling behind.

I can pretty well guess what your “advisors” are telling you. They will say you are in arbitration with the OMA, just promise to abide by the result. Honestly, I do believe you will abide by the result, both this year and next.

But…

Arbitration will take months this year, and months if not a year next year. Frankly, I doubt that the OMA, despite their strong words, will advocate for an increase of the amount necessary for comprehensive family medicine (hopefully I’m wrong).

I have absolutely no doubt that the Arbitrator, William Kaplan, will give a raise to family docs, especially after the recent award to nurses. But if the raise isn’t enough, you going out to the general public in two years and saying “we honoured the arbitrators rulings” – will make zero difference to the close to five million people who won’t have a family doctor. They will still blame you for not having been pro active.

William Kaplan, Chair of the Arbitration Board

Listen, I’m on the conservative side of the political spectrum. I’ve always voted for the Conservatives in every provincial election since I was eligible to vote. I live in Simcoe – Grey which is one of, if not the most strongly conservative ridings in Ontario. Heck, in the early 1990s we were the ONLY riding east of Manitoba to vote for a Reform Party MP.

I’m telling you that most of the voices on the ground are really upset about the lack of family doctors. We have about 7,000 patients without a family doctor in our area last I heard. It’s true that when asked who they will vote for in polls, they, like most recent polls, say they’ll vote conservative. However, they always add “I guess, there’s nobody else out there”. That softness in your vote is a problem, and that softness doesn’t show up in the poll numbers.

Listen, I want you to win the next election. I personally think the NDP would be a complete disaster. I have no faith the Liberals, who showed just how much they hate doctors, have changed their tune. But in order to do that, you’re going to need to bite the bullet, and stem the haemorrhage of family docs.

Go to tell your negotiations team to offer up a deal that strengthens family medicine. Mask the increase with things like retention bonuses (like Manitoba) and matching RRSP payments (like BC) and other methods (paid admin time, paid supervision of team members and pensions would be nice). But get it done ASAP.

Otherwise, I genuinely think you will be in more trouble than you might be led to believe by your handlers in 2026.

Your sincerely,

An old country doctor.

About Asking for Reduced Admin Burden From the MOH….

Lots of talk on the net about how the economic model for family physicians no longer works in 2024. My own blog site has had guest posts dedicated to this issue. There has been some criticism of this position. Dr. Darren Larsen in a reply to the post linked above suggests he is “not seeing or hearing…ideas for solutions“. He further states that all paying doctors more will do is create a “better-paid, unhappy professional. Nothing has changed.”

Others have made the similar comments. There is nothing philosophically wrong with the argument to reduce workload instead of raising pay. Practically speaking however, history has repeatedly taught us that the Ministry of Health (MOH) bureaucracy is incapable of delivering on that promise.

Some personal stories:

In the mid 2010s I was a Peer Lead for OntarioMD (no really!). I was frustrated by the Ontario Lab Information System (OLIS) because I had to manually retrieve all the lab work for a patient individually in their chart. Hospital Report Manager (HRM) by comparison, sends reports on all my patients directly to one inbox. (why we need two systems – and now more, is another story). The then VP of OntarioMD informed me they were working on “Practitioner Query” – which would allow me to get all my lab work from OLIS in one inbox. This was supposed to be ready in six months. That was over a decade ago.

From 2014-2018, thanks to the vision of my colleague Dr. James Lane, we developed an integrated health portal as part of our Health Links project for South Georgian Bay. For $35K a year, we were able to ensure that nursing homes could message physicians on their EMR. We dramatically reduced paperwork for physicians from nursing homes, improved health care outcomes, and reduced hospitalizations thus saving the entire health system money.

The MOH bureaucracy couldn’t wrap its head around this and wouldn’t allow it to continue.

For those of you who think I should have told people about this project, I wrote an article in the Toronto Sun about it. Afterwards, I got invited to do a presentation on this with the then CEO of eHealth Ontario and her senior team. Heck, when I was a keynote speaker at OntarioMDs Every Step conference in 2019 (no really!) I presented this project. The then head of the MOH Digital Health Team was there and heard it. Still, the bureaucracy couldn’t see their way towards allowing a project that saved physician time (and improved health care outcomes) could continue.

Ok, ok, so this blog is just for me to complain about not being listened to right? Well no, there are multiple other examples.

One workload issue for family physicians is keeping track of which of our patients get immunized for which vaccines. If only there was a central tracking system that sent the information to us directly. Wait, there is! The Covax system for tracking Covid vaccinations. Obviously the easiest and most sensible thing to do is expand the already existing system to add all the other vaccines so we get notified (eg when public health gives Gardasil). Yet 3 years after Covax, the MOH can’t even make this simple common sense change.

More? When I was on the SGFP Executive, one of our senior physicians told us the story of how he was on a working group to make the schedule of benefits (the fee schedule for Ontarios doctors) easier. After six months of meetings, they made a decision to add a comma to the descriptive sentence of one code. One comma in an 800 page schedule.

I could go on but you get the point. It’s fine for the MOH to say that that they promise to reduce the Admin burden for family docs. But frankly to these aged and cynical ears, it just sounds like them saying “This time we really mean it, honest!” – kinda like when Lucy promised to hold the football down for Charlie Brown for real this time, with predictable results.

Look, we have a five alarm crisis in family medicine in Ontario. Just about every week brings a story of another physician who is struggling with the economics of running a practice, and is considering quitting.

As with all emergencies, we need to have an effective triage system in place. Deal with the most urgent thing first, then go on to other things. We clearly can’t wait until 2034 for the MOH to implement some of the workload reducing schemes they might have (and no matter how much they promise they really mean it – it will take that long). So the first thing that needs to be done is bring financial stability to family practices so that they can continue to function while we sort out everything else.

Now, given Ontario physicians are in the midst of negotiating a new contract with the Ontario government, I expect the MOH team to say to our own negotiations team something like – “I know you guys want X% increase, but we can only give you 1/2 of that, but we promise to reduce your admin burden so you are working less hard”. I would do the same if I was them.

But, my expectation, and the expectation I think of the majority of doctors in Ontario, would be that the OMA negotiations team looks at the MOH team, and quotes the best engineer in the history of Starfleet to them.

With apologies to Geordi Laforge, B’elana Torres, Trip Tucker, Jett Reno, Andy Billups, and Hemmer – but Scotty was the BEST ENGINEER in the history of Star Trek!

The first step towards fixing the crisis in family medicine is a new physicians service agreement that stabilizes family practices. Once that’s done, work can begin anew on health systems transformation/workload reduction and so on. To try to do it the other way round, or even hand in hand, is a recipe for further collapse of the health care system.

Mark Dermer: On the Ethics of Telling Residents to Avoid Comprehensive Family Medicine

Recently Maria DiDanieli, a system navigator with the Burlington Family Health Team who holds a Masters in Medical Bioethics, wrote an article criticizing myself, Dr. Silvy Mathew and Dr. Nadia Alam for recommending family medicine residents NOT start a comprehensive care family practices at this time. Dr. Mark Dermer responded so eloquently to that, that I asked his permission to reproduce his response as a guest blogger, and he kindly agreed.

Dr. Mark Dermer, a recently retired family physician whom I’m honoured to have as a guest blogger today.

As a recently retired family physician, I am troubled by the fact that you (Maria DiDanieli) have mistaken the fact that you work adjacent to family doctors as sufficient to understand what they face. Worse, your assessment of Drs. Alam, Gandhi and Mathew is unjust.

But that’s not why I am commenting. Instead, I am coming at this as someone with some experience in medical ethics, both as a long-time member of community and teaching hospital ethics committees, and as a teacher of medical ethics to family medicine residents.

To put it simply: Your ethical analysis of my colleagues publishing the opinion piece in question is both facile and flawed.

I crafted an ABCDEF mnemonic to help residents remember six fundamental principles of medical ethics:

A – the right to Autonomy in decision-making

B – the moral duty of physicians to be adhere to Beneficence when caring for patients

C – the obligation to safeguard patient Confidentiality

D – the patient’s right to receive Disclosure of all information pertaining

E – Equity in dividing finite resources among patient populations

F – First, do no harm (nonmaleficence)

We then apply these principles to a given situation, understanding that the principles might conflict with one another. It is very rare that a single principle can be used to judge a given question. We also must accept that there are almost never absolute rights and wrongs, just better and worse answers.

I am confident that we can agree that the current primary care crisis is first and foremost a violation of equity: present circumstances have divided the people who want a family doctor into those who have one and those who don’t. I also expect that you are aware of the evidence that demonstrates that patient outcomes are better when people have an ongoing relationship with a family doctor.

But you make the elementary mistake of applying a single ethical principle, nonmaleficence, to the matter at hand. Furthermore, you seem unaware that physicians graduating from family medicine programs have been entirely consumed with their training over the previous 5-6 years, nor aware that the medical education system has largely withheld what graduating residents will face as they enter practice. In that light, the letter is a long overdue disclosure that brings transparency to the current state of family medicine.

That’s right, physicians have the right to disclosure too. We also have rights as people to autonomy, confidentiality and equity. Yet when it comes to our work, we are forced to accept legislated pay and work conditions from a monopoly payer, the government. And the government uses the fact that physicians are independent contractors to justify the fact that we are not entitled to the same cost-of-living increases paid to other health or educational professionals.

Finally, I think you fail to recognize that in family medicine, we face unusual challenges to persistently align with all the principles of medical ethics, which work best when applied to “cases” (a single patient at a single moment in time). In contrast, family physicians’ work is longitudinal and includes significant responsibility to populations of patients as well as to individuals. That means that we accept short-term harm when we do things like stick vaccination needles in people’s arms or wean them from opioids, understanding that we are looking to provide a net benefit in the medium to long term.

To my mind, that is precisely what Drs. Alam, Gandhi and Mathew have done. In other words, they are acting very ethically. For while the short-term consequences of their disclosure may accelerate the intensification of the immediate crisis, the sooner the crisis provokes action the sooner we start climbing out of this horrendous hole.

Open Letter to All Family Practice Residents

The following letter was jointly written by the three of us and published in the Toronto Star on February 20, 2024. It is being reproduced below so that we can share the letter on Facebook as we believe it will be of interest to physicians across Canada.

To All Family Medicine Residents,

We are writing to say congratulations! You are nearly at the end of a decade of hard work, perseverance and sacrifice; ready to start your career and “real life”. You have joined a beautiful and unique specialty. You will be the key to the healthcare system. You will find answers when patients arrive with ambiguous symptoms. Others will tag in and out of a patient’s health journey. You will stay and be an essential part of the beginning, middle and end of every patient’s story. You will save lives.

Your skill and knowledge are unparalleled, and there is no substitute for your expertise.

Which is why with heavy hearts, we, the undersigned, recommend that you do not start your own family medicine practice in Ontario. Not right now.

Family medicine is in crisis. Family doctors in Ontario are unable to provide the care they could and should. We face unprecedented levels of administrative burden, unsustainable business expenses, lack of healthcare resources, lack of social and cultural support for our patients and ourselves and finally, a lack of respect. This has led to widespread burnout and exhaustion.

In short, it is becoming frankly unsafe to run a family practice in Ontario, especially for those just starting.

We are family doctors with decades of experience. We are also physician leaders, past-presidents and board directors of the Ontario Medical Association (OMA), academic faculty, and health policy experts. We understand the situation well.

Do not sign that contract. Do not sign a lease, hire staff, buy equipment, contract with an EMR or any of the million things that must be done so that you can start a comprehensive care family practice.

Starting a practice at this time will require you to continue to sacrifice everything else in your life. If you have debt, you may not be able to pay it down, let alone start living the life you and many others have postponed for so long. You will struggle to spend time with your family, buy a home, care for vulnerable loved ones and more. You will continue to work at a non-stop pace, this time with no end in sight.

You will burn out and like many others, leave family medicine for good. This is why millions of Ontarians no longer have a family doctor.

The Ontario Ministry of Health can solve this crisis.

Governments in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and British Columbia have done so. This past year, they made family medicine a priority – and backed their words with targeted funding toward key programs to support both new and established doctors. It comes as no surprise that they have welcomed hundreds of new family doctors into their communities.

If they can do it, so can Ontario.

What can you do in the meantime? Work in hospitals, hospices, operating rooms and long-term care. Work in obstetrics, anesthesia, as a hospitalist, in emergency or palliative care, oncology, sports medicine etc. Be a locum. Bide your time.

You are skilled, smart, and adaptable. Your knowledge is extensive, demonstrating an unmatched depth and breadth of training. Use it.

When people leave comprehensive care family medicine, they almost never come back.

We don’t want that to happen to you. When the government of Ontario recognizes family doctors as the foundation of medical care, negotiates a fair contract and improves health policies to reflect patient needs in 2024… well, when that happens, we will write a different letter and welcome you to the world you were meant to be in.

We hope by then it is not too late.

Sincerely,

Dr. Nadia Alam, comprehensive care family physician and anesthetist, past-president of the OMA

Dr. Sohail Gandhi, comprehensive care family physician and hospitalist, past-president of the OMA

Dr. Silvy Mathew, comprehensive care family physician and long-term care, past-board director of the OMA

Dr. Soni Reflects on the Delays in Emergency Rooms

Dr. Deepa Soni, and Emergency Room physician for over twenty years, reflects on the case of a young woman with appendicitis, and the delays in getting her care.

NB: Recently, Julia Malott spoke out on X (formerly known as Twitter) about how terrified she was about Canada’s health care crisis. She wrote how her daughter had not eaten in 18 hours as she continued to wait for surgery for appendicitis. She expressed concern about the lack of the beds and wondered if her daughter would get surgery before the appendix ruptured.

My friend Dr. Soni, who has worked in an Emergency Department for over 20 years, had, as usual, a very thoughtful and well spoken X thread of her own. (Dr. Soni was NOT involved in the care of this young woman). I thank her for allowing me to reproduce her thoughts here.

The only way these stories (about long delays in Emergency rooms) will stop being the norm, is when patients start sharing their experience like this mother did. Only voters can make federal and provincial governments change because votes are the only currency that matter. Doctors and nurses have been raising alarm bells for years without success.

Canada has one of the lowest number of hospital beds of all the OECD countries, around 2.3/1000 people. In comparison countries like Japan, Korea and Germany are around 13/1000.

Graph showing how Canada fourth from the bottom (!) in hospital beds per capita.

Why does this matter? Having low hospital bed numbers means that words like “flu surge“, and “winter surge” — which have been used for decades to explain away long wait times and hallway medicine, are actually not “surges.” Rather, they are the expected backlog in a system that lacks adequate beds and resources.

The population of Canada is increasing and aging. We are about to enter a silver tsunami where a large cohort of our population will be over the age of 65 and many over the age of 85. This will place unprecedented pressures on our health care system.

What happens when the hospital bed capacity is outstripped by the numbers of patients needing care? It means that the elderly patient who needs admission to a hospital bed to recover from a heart attack has no bed to go to and spends days “admitted” in the emergency department. Bureaucrats call these “unconventional spaces.” What they really are, are stretchers.

Photo of admitted patients lying in stretchers in a hallway as no beds available (found on X)

When the vast majority of the emergency department beds are being used to take care of hospital patients, that means that patients that are waiting in the emergency department waiting room, will wait for hours for care, much like this story is describing.

Media needs to scratch beyond the surface and hold government to account. Real solutions are going to require thinking beyond the four-year election cycle. What will our system look like in 20 years? How do you plan for that?

It’s going to require recognizing the backbone of our healthcare system is primary care. Family doctors are overwhelmed by administrative burden, trying to run their offices and taking care of large practises in the community without adequate resources.

Build community infrastructure with resources like palliative care so that people can remain in their homes comfortably in their last days; and sufficient homecare services so that patients can receive antibiotics and other intravenous treatments at home to ease the pressure on hospitals. These services are vastly underfunded and do not have enough staff to properly provide care for everyone that needs it in the community.

It’s going to require building more nursing homes, retirement homes, seniors services and dementia care programs, as our elderly population will be the largest it’s ever been in this country.

Incentivize and properly pay hospital nurses so that we can recruit and retain them to be able to run departments and programs properly. Currently, agency nurses make at least two times as much as a hospital nurse, and this has created instability in the workforce. Governments need to show that they value nurses and the important work that they do.

Creative solutions like interprovincial licensing of doctors and nurses and a National Pharmacare program will help. While the idea of recruiting from other countries sounds like an easy quick fix, it will not solve anything if those newly obtained doctors and nurses find themselves overworked and burning out soon after arriving to Canada. The system problems are going to impact them just as they have impacted those who are already working in the system. This type of strain is what contributes to moral distress and burn out.

The backlog in the emergency department is a reflection of multiple failing areas that create an overall system that is strained beyond capacity. With each passing year, Canada’s healthcare system has become more and more stretched, trying to provide more care to more people, with fewer resources. Throwing Band-Aids at it is like trying to mop up the floor under an overflowing sink instead of trying to figure out how to turn off the tap.

Stories like this one are happening every day in Ontario and all of Canada. Most patients and families are too busy dealing with the acute health problem to take the time to write to their MP/MPP or to go to the media. But when people take the time to bring these stories to light, a critical tipping point will eventually occur where they can no longer be ignored by government. Because votes matter.

No one who went into healthcare wants to work in a system that makes patients feel like this story illuminated. But we need more voices bringing their stories out in the open. It will improve the system for the people working in it, and for the people receiving care within it. And that is better for everyone.

What Would I Do if I Got Sick? I Would go to Turkiye.

NB. I am a consultant for Medicte, a medical tourism firm that connects people with the Acibadem Health Group in Turkiye. I appreciate my two loyal fans may read this to be an “advertorial” – but it does represent how I feel.

Yours truly at an Acibadem Hospital in Turkiye with their team and representatives from Medicte

Recently, Leger released the findings of a survey that polled Canadians on their thoughts about the health care system. 70% of Canadians worried about not being able to get high quality health care. Surprisingly, only 37% thought the health care system was poor – did 63% not need medical care recently? But the number that should demoralize all of us is that only 17% feel the system will improve.

Like everyone else of a certain age, I’m coming to the realization that the one fight I won’t win, is the battle against time. More of my friends and colleagues are developing health issues. While I’m blessed to be in good health, like 83% of Canadians, I realize that the current health care system (which doctors call horrific and inhumane ), will not provide the access and care we should expect as standard in this country. I can only see things getting worse in the near future.

It does not help that I live in the health system every day. I’ve watched patients I really care about suffer in ways that I would not have imagined possible. Young people with cancer not getting treatment for three months. People with joint pain waiting a year for surgery. Patients developing complication after complication while on wait lists to access necessary treatments.

Most heartbreakingly, I see the toll that the burnout of working in such a hellishly damnable health care system is taking on doctors, nurses and other allied health care professionals on a daily basis.

That’s why I recently made the decision that if I, or someone in my family needed health care, I would seek care outside of Canada. I am not alone in this. The data is hard to get at, but going back as far as 2014, between 52,000 to 217,000 Canadians were seeking health care outside of Canada annually.

There are a variety of reasons to seek care outside of Canada, and specifically Türkiye:

Getting immediate care. I could get hip surgery next week, not next year. Cancer patients get all the tests they need done within a week, not three months like I’ve seen.
Getting treatments that are not available in Canada. Canada offers a host of great medical treatments, but many are not covered by government plans. Lap Band surgery is one. New, emerging radiation therapies for pancreatic cancer is another. There are more. All of these are available in Türkiye.
Getting better allied health care support. Canada has GREAT nurses and other allied health care workers. But the system does not let them care for patients the best. Last time I was on call at my hospital, I overheard the nurses talking about how they each had 7 patients to look after for the shift. The safe number for an acute care hospital ward is 5 patients per nurse. We have excellent nurses but if you are constantly working at 40% over capacity, things are not going to go well. At the Acibadem hospitals in Türkiye, they have 4 nurses for 15 patients (3.75 patients per nurse).
More cost effective care. I’m fortunate I can afford to pay out of pocket for care if needed. Worst comes to worst I’ll put off retirement for a couple of years to pay for things if necessary. But even I would have trouble with $200,000 (U.S.!) that B. C. resident Allison Ducluzeau spent on her cancer care. Costs in Türkiye for most procedures I looked at are generally less than half of what it costs in the U.S.
First World Standards for Health Care Treatments. All of the Acibadem hospitals are JCI Accredited (the global leader in health care accreditation agencies). This puts them on par (and in some cases better) than top European hospitals.
Türkiye is a well sought after Medical Tourism destination. Medical Travel Market recently highlighted 12 reasons why Türkiye was so well sought after including cost, world class facilities and cutting edge treatments. 1.2 million people went to Türkiye for medical tourism in 2022, mostly from Europe.

As part of my consulting work, I went on a fact finding tour to Türkiye and visited the Acibadem hospitals. To say my jaw dropped would be an understatement.

The team and I reviewing the process for orthopaedic care with their top spine surgeon.

The hospitals (there are 21 in the Acibadem group) look like hotels. Each room is private. The wards are immaculate. All of the staff were incredibly attentive (and yes, spoke English).

I asked to see the MRI, and the staff wanted to know which one (!). Their approximately 170 bed hospital had THREE MRIs, specialized for different conditions. This is on top of the CT scans, gamma knives (cancer treatment), PET scans etc etc. All of the equipment was brand new. I especially liked the MRI that projected a movie onto the equipment, to help children stay calm during the procedure.

This MRI projects a movie onto the surface to help children (and some adults) stay calm during a claustrophobic procedure

I also ran into a couple of top ranked Turkish footballers (soccer players) while there. The Turks are as crazy about football as we are about hockey. Their top athletes go to the Acibadem group.

But what’s more impressive than the top ranked doctors, nurses and equipment is their philosophy of how to provide health care. If you were to sadly, get cancer, you would see all the specialists you need to see (surgeon, medical oncologist, radiation oncologists etc) on the same day. Any tests you need would be organized sequentially and rapidly over the next couple of days (if not the same day). You would have a full treatment plan within a few days.

Contrast this with Canada where you have to have an appointment with one doctor, then wait x number of weeks to see another then x to see another like my patients currently do. All while the cancer continues to grow.

Also, for the record, I did wind up getting care myself at Acibadem. Bad teeth run in my family, and so I went for a dental check up. The dentist examined me, put in two fillings, got the oral surgeon to come by and took out two teeth that were beyond hope, all during the same visit. This would have taken multiple visits in Canada. You could say I put my money where my mouth is. And yes, the care was excellent.

I appreciate this sounds like an advertorial. But the reality is that more and more Canadians are getting frustrated with the long waits for health care and seeking care outside of Canada. It may have started off with people seeking lower cost cosmetic surgery, but now things like orthopaedic surgery, cancer treatments, organ transplants, dental implants and even cutting edge infertility treatments can be had for those willing to travel.

There is never a guarantee of a successful result with medical treatments anywhere (including Canada). If considering leaving the country for care, people should do their due diligence. Make sure you deal with a reputable firm and first rate hospital.

I’ve made my decision, and I know where I’ll go.

If you or anyone else would like to explore options for out of country health care, contact Medicte for a free consultation.