Family Medicine – Page 3 – justanoldcountrydoctor

Will the OMA Learn Lessons from OHIP’s Latest Attack on Doctors?

Last Friday (May 2), in what was a classic Friday afternoon bureaucratic dump, the OHIP bureaucrats at the Ministry of Health announced that they wouldn’t be paying the full amount of back pay owed Ontario’s doctors, as per the arbitration award. This was a unilateral decision on their part. It was contrary to what was in a signed agreement, and the OMA Board was notified at the last minute. (OMA CEO Kim Moran’s email is attached to the bottom of this blog). The bureaucrats promptly ran away an hid for the weekend hoping this issue would go away (kind of like how Sam Bennett cowardly hid from the press after putting an elbow to Leafs goalie Anthony Stolarz head).

This is, in my opinion, the latest attack on physicians as a whole from Ministry of Health (MOH) bureaucrats, who clearly are more interested in trench warfare than working co-operatively with Ontario’s doctors to improve health care for the citizens of Ontario. Don’t believe me? Consider the following:

The bureaucrats had the option of realizing that provinces like Manitoba/BC/Saskatchewan and even Alberta(!) recognized the need to work with their doctors and come up with a funding formula for them. Instead they chose to drag Ontario’s physicians through a protracted (going on three years now) and highly antagonistic arbitration/negotiations process.

Not only that, in response to now multiple stories of people lining up to find a family doctor in the press, their response was that there was “no concern” about the shortage of comprehensive family care physicians. (Seriously, how out of touch must they be to think that that type of Orwellian double speak is going to work in Canada).

People lined up hoping to get a family doctor in Walkerton. Photo originally posted in the farmers forum.

Frankly, this inept, combative and dismissive treatment of physicians is just par for the course for this bunch of bureaucrats. It saddens me, but it doesn’t surprise me.

No blame for this decision should fall to the OMA. They did negotiate a signed agreement (as per Ms. Moran’s email) and they clearly were not notified about the unilateral change until far too late. So the unilateral action is not their fault.

But….

What the OMA can, and should be held accountable for is how they proceed from here.

I don’t want to seem overly difficult here. If I truly was an obstinate person, I’d try to get a job at the Ministry of Health – perhaps on their Negotiations Team. The reality is that I actually have a long history of working co-operatively with government to improve health care in my neck of the woods.

I’m serious. In 2001 I helped bring in the first stage of Primary Care Reform called the Family Health Group. In 2004 I was one of the lead physicians who brought in a capitation model of payment for family physicians (it was initially a Family Health Network and it eventually evolved into a Family Health Organization). From 2007 -2013 I was the founding Chair of the Georgian Bay Family Health Team and From 2013-2015 I was the Health Links lead physician in my area.

And in each of these roles I worked closely and co-operatively with government to try to improve the health care needs of the patients in my area.

But – in those days, the bureaucrats wanted to work with doctors. They wanted to co-operate to improve health care and they were genuinely concerned about the lack of family physicians providing comprehensive care. They didn’t want to play power games with physicians or harass them or do dumb things like the current crop just did.

It’s important for the OMA to (finally) realize that there really is no hope that they can work with the current lot. They’ve already dragged us through three miserable years of negotiation/arbitration and fought us (thankfully often times stupidly – as even the Arbitrator pointed out) – for the sake of…….. I don’t know why really. Maybe it’s a power play? Maybe there are just bullies?

Recognizing the obstinance of the MOH bureaucrats is why I was proud (and still am) to have my name on an Op-Ed in the Toronto Star last year advising Family Medicine Residents to NOT start a practice in Ontario at this time. But I have to tell you the blowback from the OMA was saddening to me. I will not mention names – but one senior exec told me that the OMA was working well with the Government. Worse, one senior physician leader texted me the following:

Text from a very senior physician leader at the OMA

Remember – at the time this text was sent to me – we had already been locking horns at the negotiations table for two years and the government had done absolutely nothing to solve the family medicine crisis. Perhaps the physician leader felt the relationship was “best ever” because at least they weren’t sabotaging doctors left right and centre like the abhorrent Eric Hoskins did.

Despite all of that, there was some movement forward with arbitration. While no where near what other provinces got, it at least recognized the need to fund health care better, and provided hope for funding for offices, clinics, and frankly other badly needed resources.

Now the MOH has decided unilaterally to not pay, or pay whenever they feel like it, so we are back to – do NOT start to work in Ontario.

At any rate – as mentioned, while the OMA cannot be judged on decisions by the Ministry, what the organization does next will be telling. Will they finally recognize that the current lot of bureaucrats simply cannot be dealt with by reason? Will they recognize that physicians are essentially being bullied by these ruffians and the best way to deal with a bully is to stand up to them? Will they take legal action (according to Ms. Moran’s email – there was a signed agreement which the MoH is now in violation of)?

I don’t know the answer to any of the above. But I can only hope that the current Board recognizes that there is no hope of working in good faith with this lot of bureaucrats and that strong, frankly militant actions, are needed to support the members.

Addendum: After I published my original blog, an anonymous colleague asked that I publish a link to a survey about this issue. I’ve therefore appended my blog and ask all Ontario physicians to click on the link below and honestly reply to the questions:

https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/W2ZPMCC

OMA’s Recent Messages to Family Physicians are Disappointing and Misleading

Last week, Alberta, the province that once had a health Minister who went to a physicians house to berate him in person, created a new pay model for their family physicians. Even Alberta, the province whose premier told the health service to not talk about vaccines, realized the obvious. Family physicians need to be paid commensurate to the foundational work they do, and the role they play, in a high functioning health system.

Alberta Premier Danielle “Covid? What Covid?” Smith

I’ve taken a look at the new Alberta model. Some of the specifics are gated but the rough overall numbers are public. My back of napkin math suggests there is about a 24% increase in gross income for family physicians with a practice size of 1200. This includes payments for indirect work (checking labs, reviewing reports, supervising staff – all the admin work that Ontario refuses to recognize) and increased payments for more complex patients. I congratulate my colleagues in Alberta on this accomplishment. It WILL stabilize not only family medicine, but their whole health care system.

In response OMA CEO Kimberly Moran sent out an email on Friday Dec 20th. (A complete guess on my part is that she saw some of the responses to this deal on Social Media). I personally was offended (but not surprised) by the manipulation of figures and data in her email. While it’s true that every thing she wrote in the email was technically correct, the manner in which it was presented created an impression of successes that just aren’t there when it comes to advocating for family physicians.

I hate to talk numbers, this stuff gets confusing. But here’s a short set of data you need to know (numbers rounded for simplicity).

2022/23 is the BASE YEAR for all future increases negotiated/arbitrated going forward
The 2022/23 physicians budget was $16 billion
For 2023/24 (the last year of the previous agreement) the OMA negotiated a 2.8% ($448 million) increase
for 2024/25 the Arbitrator awarded us 9.95% compounded to the 2.8% from 2023/24 – which winds up being 13.03% more than the BASE YEAR ($2.08 Billion more than 2022/23)

So what’s the problem? Well for starters Ms. Moran states that the OMA “successfully” advocated for a 9.95% increase without mentioning that the OMA asked for 22.9%. Getting less than half of what you ask for is successful? But more importantly she went on to tell family physicians that they will receive a higher increase than the arbitration award of 9.95%. (11.75 – 13.54% depending on the practice model). But here’s the thing, the arbitration award was the increase for one year only (2024/25). The increase that family doctors are getting is an increase from the BASE YEAR (2022/23) – so it reflects your increase for two years not one like the arbitration award. The two year increase to the physicians budget is, as mentioned above 13.02%.

Now I completely respect the fact that the numbers that I’m quoting do not reflect the fact that the the award is meant to be split 70/30 between fee increases and targeted funds (but neither did Ms. Moran’s email!!). A very brief summary of how targeted funds are supposed to work:

70% of the $2.08 billion are supposed to go to fee increases ($1.456 billion)
the other 30% is supposed to be targeted ( $624 million)
of the $1.456 billion, 25% ($364 million) is supposed to go to across the board (ATB) increases for everybody. Crunching the numbers means everyone gets a 2.27% increase to their 2022/23 (BASE YEAR) income. The rest of the increase is based on relativity. Ophthalmologists for example get an additional 0.18% for relativity, and family doctors get between 9.48 – 11.27% additional for relativity. But again – that’s the increase for TWO YEARS, whereas the 9.95% was just for the one year.

This type of sophistry in messaging from the OMA regarding family medicine is sadly all too common. For example, the OMA has said that Ontario Family doctors have the highest capitation rates in Canada. Is that statement true? Of course it is. BUT – what’s also true is that no other province has deductions for outside use. Also, at a bare minimum family physicians in British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Alberta and Manitoba (with Manitoba being on top) pay family physicians more. Maybe Nova Scotia as well. Ignoring that while trumpeting higher overall capitation payments is unsettling.

While I sadly did expect such sleight of hand over numbers from OMA central, I must admit I was very disappointed in the SGFP email that came shortly thereafter. The SGFP has recently really gotten quite a bit stronger at advocating for family doctors and done some good work. But even they sadly fell into the trap when SGFP Chair Dave Barber told members in his letter:

“…Family doctors will receive increases greater than the 9.95% arbitration award announced earlier this year”.

David Barber – Chair of the Section of General and Family Practice

Again, technically a true statement, but very inappropriate. I don’t know what he was thinking signing off on that.

The really sad thing is that it didn’t have to be this way. The OMA (and SGFP) could have been completely forthright and honest and simply laid out the facts as I did above. This still shows family doctors getting a relativity bump more than a lot of other specialties. And they could have said that they want a good chunk of the targeted funds to go to Family Medicine but the government continues to fight them. Finally, they could have blamed the government for not recognizing the seriousness of the crisis. All of that still would have talked about the positive work being done, without creating the impression that they were trying to hoodwink the members. But alas……

What can we done? Well, I’ve said it many times before. Only the members can change the OMA if they want to. This year in particular, four physician members are up for election for Board Director – which represents half of all the physician positions. There are also multiple candidates running for SGFP executive positions. This really represents the best opportunity in a long time to continue to change the culture at the OMA so that we don’t get disingenuous messaging like this.

I’ll have my thoughts on the election in an upcoming blog.

Dr. Elaine Ma Case is Proof Ontario is Unfriendly to Physicians

Last week, the Ontario Health Sector Appeal and Review Board (HSARB) denied the appeal by Dr. Elaine Ma in her fight against the Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP). At the risk of upsetting Dr. Ma and many (? all) of my colleagues, that decision actually was legally appropriate. HSARB can’t actually look at whether a case is reasonable or not, their job is to go by what’s written in bulletins/updates. The real affront to physicians is that it should never ever have gotten here in the first place.

The Background

For non-physicians reading this, here is a condensed summary of what happened. It’s 2020. The Covid pandemic is raging. Ontario Premier Doug Ford appoints General Rick Hillier to oversee the Covid Vaccination program. He’s tasked with, as Ford calls it, “the largest vaccine rollout in a generation, a massive logistical undertaking, the likes of which this province has never seen.” Hillier’s stated goal? To get shots in everyone’s arms by August 2021.

Dr. Elaine Ma from Kingston realizes the need to act quickly to help her community. She organizes outdoor mass vaccination clinics. Over 35,000 shots were given and Kingston became the most vaccinated area of the province. Dr. Ma was given an Award of Excellence by the Ontario College of Family Physicians for her efforts.

Picture of an outdoor vaccination clinic found elsewhere on the web

The Dispute with OHIP

So what happened? For the Covid vaccine clinics, there were two sets of billing codes assigned. The first was a standard hourly rate. This was meant for physicians who attend a vaccine clinic and perform immunizations there. There were numerous such clinics set up by hospitals/public health/pharmacies and so on. Those agencies paid for the setup costs of those clinics. The physician just showed up and vaccinated.

The second set of codes is used by physicians who give vaccinations in clinics they set up. These codes pay somewhat more, but they’re meant to compensate physicians for the fact that they have to cover all the overhead in those clinics.

Dr. Ma would have had to make sure that things like electricians were hired to ensure that there was power and Internet access outdoors. She may have needed to arrange for commercial grade outdoor tents. Propane heaters to heat the tents and the propane might have been needed. Some staff were paid (others volunteered). All of this organizational work, and figuring out payments, needed to be done in advance. She did it.

She therefore billed OHIP the second code. This is entirely reasonable given the circumstances and the work she did.

So what happened?

The sudden increase in billings did not go unnoticed by OHIP and was flagged. This is absolutely appropriate. As taxpayers, we need to be sure that there is a mechanism to catch outlying bills. The anomaly was sent for review by the various bureaucrats at OHIP. Also appropriate.

So what went wrong?

Basically everything after that. The OHIP bureaucrats reviewed the situation. As pointed out by Perry Brodkin (OHIPs former lawyer, who was quoted extensively in the Kingstonist) – the information was sent “up the hierarchy” and would have reached the deputy health minister and minister.

Former Deputy Minister of Health Dr. Catherine Zahn

The bureaucrats and health minister decided she didn’t qualify for the codes. The reasons given (see the Kingstonist articles for more details) change at a whim. First it was that the clinic was outdoors not inside (you mean at a time when we are all social distancing – we should have crammed unrelated people into a clinic to immunize them??). Then it was that medical students were used (despite the strong endorsement of using medical students by the then Dean of Queen’s University Medical School, Dr. Jane Philpott). Then it was that she paid people to work there.

Dr. Jane Philpott – former Dean of Queen’s University Medical School – and a strong supporter of the vaccination clinics set up by Dr. Ma

Then things got ugly

And finally, after repeated questioning by the Kingsonist, things got really ugly when Hannah Jensen, the communications director for the Minister of Health issues a statement alleging that Dr. Ma “pocketed” the funds. This basically amounted to an allegation of theft by Dr. Ma and was widely viewed as a disgusting, immoral and reprehensible comment in the medical community. Even the Kingstonist was alarmed by this and called the statement “rife with allegations.”

Hannah Jensen, Communications Director for Minister of Health Sylvia Jones (photo from LinkedIn Profile page)

Why this offends doctors so much.

Let’s be clear about this. There is zero tolerance in the broader medical community for misappropriation of funds/intentional fraudulent OHIP billing. Zilch. Nada. But there is a recognition that the imperfect OHIP billing schedule needs to be interpreted with reason, especially when times are unreasonable (and what could possibly be a more unreasonable time than a once in a lifetime pandemic?).

Dr. Ma did all the work to meet the billing criteria (even the OHIP bureaucrats were forced to admit that yes, over 35,000 shots were given and yes she had planned and organized the whole thing). The fact that she did it outside and had medical students help when some 20 year old pre pandemic memos said not to is an unwarranted use of a technicality.

For many physicians, this brings back memories of when another set of bureaucrats persecuted physicians. They even told one paediatric respirologist that in order to bill a code, he had to perform rectal and pelvic exams on children!

What does this mean for Ontario Health care?

First, as Dr. Ma herself pointed out, it is now illegal for physicians to bill any procedures that they delegated to medical students. This means that medical teaching will effectively grind to a halt. Why would any doctor teach a medical student to say, suture a wound, when that doctor would now be financially penalized?

Second, this story has made the national press. It has also been reported in Canadian Journals that cater to physicians and other health care workers. The message to them is clear. Do NOT think of relocating/starting up a practice in Ontario. You will be treated grossly unfairly by the bureaucrats and health minister and there will be no reasonable interpretation of the rules.

What can be done?

According to Brodkin, Health Minister Sylvia Jones and Premier Doug Ford can direct OHIP to disregard the HSARB ruling. They need to do so immediately. However, because politicians only think of re-election, and not what is right, Dr. Ramsey Hijazi, the founder of the Ontario Union of Family Physicians wants to up the pressure on them.

Dr. Ramsey Hijazi, founder of the Ontario Union of Family Physicians – pictured inset.

His group has set up a petition that clearly demands that justice be done in this case. It demands that the Minister and Premier disregard the HSARB ruling. We need to support our health care heroes not penalize them on technicalities in outdated bulletins.

I urge all of my followers to sign the petition. If this case is allowed to go on, trust me on this, there will be negative consequences for health care in Ontario, and we don’t need any more of those.

Click here to sign the petition.

Sunday Snippets: Dec 1, 2024 (ft. Bonnie Crombie, Vaccines, Microplastics and more)

Item: More and more family doctors are turning to AI scribes to reduce their workload. Many physicians in the article state time saving is the main driver for adopting these scribes.

My thoughts: I’m piloting an AI scribe right now with my Health Team. It can reduce the number of hours spent on paperwork. However, one does need to review the note dictated to ensure it’s accurate (a few examples of mistakes so far). The notes also tend to be wordier than my own notes. Finally, it’s really important to review the examination section of the notes – as the scribe has no way of knowing what a patient “looks like” and it’s up to you to ensure accuracy.

There are of course some privacy concerns. That’s why I like the fact that the scribe I’m using is not integrated into my Electronic record. That way the patients name/date of birth/health card/other identifying information does not get sent into the ether when the scribe generates a note.

My hope is the government settles on one scribe (after appropriate vetting) and pays for all physicians to use it. This will have significant positive benefits for health care.

Item: Ontario Liberal Party Leader Bonnie Crombie has launched her first campaign ad. She blames current Conservative Premier Doug Ford for the shortage of Family Physicians.

My thoughts: It’s a bit rich for the Liberals to blame the current government for the doctor shortage when most of the problems with family medicine began during their tenure. But, just as federal/national elections are won based on the cost of living/inflation (the big reason why Trump won), provincial elections in Canada are often lost based on how the current government is managing health care. And this truly is Doug Ford’s Achilles heel.

I know it seems like Ford’s handlers have him convinced that he can win a third term if only he calls an early election. But the blunt reality is that an early election call will be viewed as cynical even by people who will vote for him. Similarly the $200 Ontario “rebate” cheques are going to be viewed as a bribe.

Will Ford win a third term? I don’t know. But I doubt it will be as easy as he or his handlers think. He really needs to take some significant steps between now and the spring on health care. If only some would give him advice, and on more than one occasion.

Item: We’ve all heard about the rise in measles cases across the country and in the U.S. It seems that now Whooping Cough is also on the rise.

My thoughts: Jeez. Get vaccinated and get your kids vaccinated already people.

Item: On that note, it seems very few adults in the United States are getting updated Covid/Flu and RSV vaccines, even in high risk populations like nursing homes.

My thoughts: Life expectancy in the United States continues to fall. These two articles are not unrelated.

Item: Microplastics have now been found in the human brain.

My thoughts: Not nearly enough attention is being paid to this story. There are significant red flags for the harm that microplastics can do to human health including increasing the risk of dementia/heart disease/stroke and reducing fertility and sexual function. While it’s true that most of the studies raising alarm have been in labs or in animal models that don’t give a complete picture of the effect on humans, there are just too many concerns to ignore. We need an urgent review of microplastics (along with a review of all the processed garbage in the North American diet).

Item: A great article in the Annals of Family Medicine shows that when your doctor is away, there is LESS downstream use of ER and associated health care costs if you see a doctor in the same group practice than in a walk in clinic.

My thoughts: This is yet another reason why expansion of scope of allied health professionals is a bad idea. Rather than getting your care fragmented between health care workers who don’t have your full health history – the ideal is to support your family doctor to make sure whoever is covering can see that information, to give you better care. And on that note….

Item: Ontario is going to allow the further expansion of scope of nurse practitioners. PEI is going to allow physiotherapists to order X-rays.

My thoughts: Go read the article from Annals of Family Medicine above. This move (to expand scope) will eventually be shown to have been a big mistake.

Item: Excellent (and unusual for the Trillium – ungated) article on the aging population of family physicians in Ontario and what it could mean for the future.

My thoughts: None of this is surprising. Four of the five doctors in my clinic are late 50s or older. We are heading for a real problem if we don’t immediately support family medicine now.

Item: I somehow missed this but it seems that Australia just had its worst flu season on record.

My thoughts: I wrote this in 2017 warning that our health care system couldn’t handle a bad flu season. The situation is worse now. I don’t know what the flu season will be like, but if it’s a bad one we will see a proliferation of horror stories about health care. At the risk of sounding like a broken record – get your flu shot people. Keep yourself safe.

Yours truly getting his flu shot this year.

That’s it for this week. I’m away next week. Might have a blog later on a specific issue that is making Ontario an undesirable location to practice medicine. Back in two weeks with more snippets.

Bureaucratic Stupidity in Covid Vaccine Clinic Case Will Have Far Reaching Consequences

I’ve repeatedly been told that I am too unkind and too harsh to Ministry of Health (MOH) bureaucrats. A senior staff member at the OMA once suggested I was “out of line” to a very sharp (but necessary) scolding I gave an MOH bureaucrat at a bilateral meeting we had. About a month later, that same senior staff person, when on a voice conference call with the same bureaucrat, got up and wrote “This is a waste of time” on a chalkboard at OMA headquarters. But I digress.

Yet every time I try to pull back, these same bureaucrats go and do something that is so incomprehensibly stupid that I once again wonder about the talent level and frankly intelligence of the bureaucracy as a whole at the MOH.

On this occasion, I’m referring to the Ontario Health Insurance Plan’s (OHIP) relentless persecution of Dr. Elaine Ma. The whole mess has been extensively reported and you can read all the details in the links, but I will summarize key points below:

October 25, 2024

Dr. Ma’s clinic in Kingston suddenly cancelled its October 26 drive thru flu/covid vaccine clinic. Over 600 patients had registered with more pending. The reason is that OHIP had notified her that she would not be paid to vaccinate patients at the clinic. Why? Because she was going to have medical students (who would be supervised) vaccinate. According to a 2001 bulletin OHIP pulled out, students are not employees and so she can’t delegate to them. (OHIPs story keeps changing and you’ll see that further down the blog). It also emerged that OHIP was attempting to recoup funds paid to her for running similar vaccine clinics in 2021.

October 30, 2024

It was now reported that OHIP was demanding Dr. Ma repay $600,000 that she billed to run outdoor vaccination clinics. She ran a number of mass Covid vaccinations clinics that gave over 35,000 shots. These were set up by her in response to the provinces call to “get shots in peoples arms“at the height of the Covid pandemic. Dr. Ma was widely lauded for her efforts at the time – and won the Ontario College of Family Physicians award of Excellence. Her area became the most vaccinated area of the province, something that should be celebrated.

OHIP now claims that she didn’t follow the rules for billing. Their excuse this time? That clinic was outdoors and not in a doctor’s office. (I told you OHIPs story would keep changing). Yes, you did read that right. In the middle of a pandemic caused by an airborne virus, OHIP wanted the vaccination clinics to be held in crowded indoor spaces!

November 1, 2024

Dr. Ma had rapidly gained the public support of the local medical officer of health (there was likely background support previously). She also had the support (previously background now public) of her MPP, the OMA and many others. She did not get the public support of Dr. Jane Philpott. Dr. Philpott, in her role as Dean of Queens Medical school was full of praise for the clinics. I suspect Dr. Philpott has 550,000 reasons to stay quiet publicly now. Hopefully she can influence behind the scenes.

OHIP now stated that the concern was that Dr. Ma used some of the funds to pay the staff who worked there. You read that right. They were worried because a physician billed OHIP (gasp!) then took the funds to pay overhead (double gasp!!). The horror!

Hannah Jensen, the Minister of Health’s Communications Director initially simply parroted the line that OHIP bureaucrats fed her about being ineligible to bill because of using medical students and it being outdoors. But she was rapidly exposed as being completely out of her depth when the Kingstonist questioned her about dates, which doctor, which clinics, how she arrived at figures and so on.

Additionally, her tone took a seriously ugly and aggressive turn. There was an accusation that Dr. Ma “pocketed the funds” which essentially is an accusation of theft. (No law enforcement is involved….yet).

November 7, 2024

The story hit the national news and it was reported that not only was OHIP asking Dr. Ma to pay back $600,000, but they were demanding $35K in interest as well (!). Who knew OHIP bureaucrats moonlighted as loan sharks??

November 8, 2024

Dr. Hijazi, leader of the Ontario Union of Family Physicians was interviewed by the CBC . He obviously was supportive of Dr. Ma demanded that the Ministry apologize to her. The Ministry issued an utterly and completely delusional statement to CBC radio stating that claims Ontario can’t get family physicians are “fictitious”. (Listen to the last 30 seconds at the link). 2.5 million people can’t get a family doctor in this province because doctors don’t want to work comprehensive care is “fictitious”????

Nothing much to see here. Just a fictitious clinic in Kingston, where fictitious people without a family doctor lined up hoping to get a doctor because a fictitious family doctor announced a new practice..

What consequences are there to this?

To0 many to mention, and they are all awful. Perry Brodkin, OHIPs former lawyer was quoted extensively in the articles about process. He pointed out that before attempting to recoup these funds, the bureaucrats would have run it up the chain to the deputy minister if not the health minister. There is therefore no doubt that this egregious action is one of the bureaucracy as a whole as opposed to one rogue bureaucrat. This cements the feeling that many physicians increasingly have had that bureaucrats as a whole are malicious (especially after the nonsense they claimed during arbitration).

It also badly threatens medical teaching. If the appeal that Dr. Ma filed is unsuccessful, then it essentially means that physicians would not get paid for teaching medical students. Which would effectively end teaching in Ontario. How exactly do you plan to replace the current supply of physicians as they age out, if no one will teach new ones?

With the story hitting the national news on CBC, it also will significantly impair attempts to recruit physicians from out of province. We are already losing younger doctors to provinces like BC and Manitoba where they see a co-operative relationship between government and physicians. Why would any of them come to a Province where you are called a hero one day, and then publicly embarrassed, harassed and vilified over a clearly outdated memo that needed to put aside during a once in a lifetime pandemic?

What SHOULD happen next (but probably won’t)

Unfortunately, Brodkin also points out that at this point there is nothing that will influence the appeal board. The process could have been stopped earlier before the hearing, but Sylvia Jones and her staff chose not to. But, if Dr. Ma wins, the government should immediately announce they will not appeal the decision to the courts. Additionally, Hannah Jensen needs to publicly apologize for her…..out of line…..comment on “pocketing” funds. And Sylvia Jones should also offer up an apology to Dr. Ma for the failure of her bureaucrats to recognize that rigid adherence to minutiae in a time of crisis is completely unacceptable.

Finally, what badly needs to be done is that the entire Ministry of Health bureaucracy needs to be given a very large enema to clear out the…….

Sunday Snippets – November 17, 2024

Another in a weekly series of brief snippets of health care stories that bemused, intrigued and otherwise beguiled me over the past week along with my random thoughts on the matter.

Item: New reports show that marijuana use is linked to thinning of brains in adolescents.

My thoughts: It’s not just adolescents. And it’s not just brains. I’ve seen a marked rise in people with significant mood issues ever since marijuana was legalized. There has also been a significant rise in people with stomach/bowel issues in my practice that all other tests turn up negative for. Patients with these issues are invariably marijuana users and the blunt reality is they won’t get better until they stop. I continue to be in favour of decriminalizing marijuana and other illicit street drugs if and only if we do it the way Portugal did it and not the haphazard way it is being done in Canada. But we really need to re-think the full on legalization of it.

Item: A survey in Medscape showed that there were two factors critical to reducing family medicine burnout. First would be to reduce the Electronic Health Record burden, particularly the number of times family physicians have to chart from home. Second would be to build stronger physician/nurse teams. Crucially, the teams need to be led by the family physician and NOT a bureaucrat or some other team member.

My thoughts: I hope this finally gets the Canadian Medical Association (which despite over $2 billion dollars in their bank account is amazingly growing increasingly irrelevant to front line physicians) to SHUT UP ABOUT SICK NOTES ALREADY. That’s not going to solve burnout (even though I like every other doctor hate doing them). To paraphrase a political slogan – “It’s the Electronic Health Record, stupid.” My second thought is that I remain extremely concerned that while I do feel Dr. Jane Philpott is well intentioned in her new role (to lead a primary care action team) – the bureaucrats at Ontario Health will sabotage her. They will see “teams help”, then create teams that have the assistant to the secretary to the aide to deputy minister’s attache for the Primary Care Secretariat’s deputy vice president run them. That will be a disaster. Teams need to be led by family physicians. Full stop.

Dr. Jane Philpott, head of the new “Primary Care Action Team” designed to give everyone access to primary care in 5 years.

Item(s): The family physician crisis in Ontario continues to worsen. Tillsonburg lost four family physicians. Wallaceburg is launching a large physician recruitment program to deal with their shortage. Brantford is taking a more hands on role to get more family physicians. Brockville is hiring a consulting firm that employs former health Minister George Smitherman to help tackle their shortage.

My thoughts: It’s sad that we are in a seeming “Hunger Games” of one community fighting another for the precious resource that is a family doctor. If only someone had warned people a crisis was coming. Oh, right.

Dr. Nadia Alam, who, like others, warned that the crisis in family medicine (and health in care in general) was coming ten years ago, and was ignored by governments.

Item: Premier Ford promises to correct the mistakes at Ontario Health at Home that led to a large amount of suffering for patients. He also stated that the people who “messed this up” will be “held accountable”.

My thoughts: I’ll believe it when I see it. When I wrote about mismanaged bureaucracy in health care (back in 2015!) I pointed out that no decision seems to get made by bureaucrats without continuously “circling back” to one committee or another. The reason I’ve discovered, is because this way, no individual gets blamed for (the very many) bad decisions made in health care. I’ve yet to see a health care bureaucrat fired – and I’ve met many who deserved to be. I really hope that the comments by Premier Ford signal a return to the old Doug Ford who promised to end the “gravy train” and famously said:

“What drives me crazy is when you have a supervisor in government, and they report into 12 other supervisors. That’s unacceptable.“

Doug Ford, Premier of Ontario for almost 7 years, and the gravy train in Ontario Heath continues unabated

Item: Male doctors are working less hours in a week than they used to. They are still working more than the average Canadian worker, but there has been an unmistakable decrease in how many hours they work

My thoughts: Finally! Proof that men are getting smarter! There’s more to life than work, and good for the younger docs – all of them – for seeking balance in their lives.

Item: A young Ontario mother died of cholangiocarcinoma (cancer of the gall bladder), after encountering multiple road blocks getting a new treatment (Pemigatnib) approved for her.

My thoughts: This story is absolutely infuriating and encapsulates what is wrong with our health care system. Look, there is no guarantee that she would have survived if she had gotten the treatment (it’s an awful cancer she had). BUT – look at all the regulatory agencies involved in getting the drug approved. Health Canada approved the drug in 2021. But the Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technology in Health said the evidence wasn’t clear. (So why then did Health Canada approve it?). Furthermore there are multiple provincial drug agencies involved, which means she could have gotten it had she been a resident of Quebec, but not Ontario (two tier medicine anyone?). It’s the bureaucracy and double speak from having too many agencies involved that angers me greatly. A wholesale streamlining of the process for medication approvals is desperately needed.

That’s all for this week. Back next week (probably) with more.

Sunday Snippets – November 10, 2024

Another in a weekly series of brief snippets of health care stories that bemused, intrigued and otherwise beguiled me over the past week along with my random thoughts on the matter.

Item: An article in the College of Family Physicians of Canada Journal suggests that “recycling” physicians would help address family physician shortages. This includes “Physicians who have had successful careers in general surgery, emergency medicine, family medicine, hospitalist practices, and other specialties…”

My thoughts: Sigh. I get that the Journal is trying to be open to all views to stir discussion. I get that we are in a family practice crisis in all of Canada right now and looking at unique ways of helping. But seriously – you want to turn a retired general surgeon into a pseudo family doctor? Do you realize just how much you are denigrating family physicians by writing that a good chunk of their jobs can be replaced by people who haven’t done the residency? Some ideas belong in the trash heap and this one deserves to go there. Comprehensive care family physicians CANNOT BE REPLACED by anyone other than another properly trained comprehensive care family physician.

Item: It seems that Quebec is looking to find ways to force doctors to stay in the province and work in their public health system. They are even willing to as far as considering to use the Notwithstanding clause in the Constitution (which they would have to, as their initial position impinges on freedom of movement/assembly to make this happen).

My thoughts: It really does kill me to use Star Wars memes instead of Star Trek ones (really and truly). But once again, for this issue – I’m going to quote Star Wars character Princess Leia:

I honestly don’t know what to do with politicians anymore. There is ample, repeated, overwhelming evidence that whenever they pick fights with physicians, they inevitably lose and health care suffers. And yet they keep doing it.

Item: Dr. Corli Barnes (who I was honoured to have as a guest blogger) wrote in McLean’s Magazine (cover story no less!) about why she moved to Madoc, Ontario and the incentives they provided. I understand she took less than what is listed in the article’s headline, but there were incentives.

My thoughts: I’m happy for Dr. Barnes. I’m happy for the people in her community as well, as they are going to get healthcare from a dedicated family physician and their well being will improve as a result. But I really do wish that our system was no so fragmented and that all communities could offer a consistent level of support to their family physicians.

Item: Premier Doug Ford told patients with minor illnesses not to go to the ER. In response, Drs. Drummond and Venugopal had an op ed where they point out that the Premier is not qualified to determine what is an Emergency.

My thoughts: This will surprise some of you who know that I personally favour the Tommy Douglas model of health care, which supports user fees to dissuade misuse of the health care system. However, that is frankly up to the patients to decide for themselves. Drs. Drummond and Venugopal are correct in saying that politicians are not qualified to hand out medical advice, and should not be saying stuff like this.

Item: A study out of Michigan suggests that more virtual care will not lead to more unnecessary testing. A huge concern has been that if you cannot see a patient in person to assess this, a physician would be more likely to order a test “just to be sure”. This study suggests no.

My thoughts: I think the big flaw of this study is that it looked at patients who were in existing practices getting virtual care from their own physicians. There is a HUGE difference between getting care from your own physician virtually, or getting it virtually from someone you have never met before on some fancy looking app. The two are not the same and it would be very interesting to see how many unnecessary tests are done when there isn’t a pre-existing physician/patient relationship.

Item: Amina Zafar had an excellent piece in the CBC writing about how poorly managed your medical information is. She builds on the story of Greg Price, an unfortunate 31 year old who died of testicular cancer, when he probably shouldn’t have. She writes how this mismanagement of health care information is common in Canada.

My thoughts: Yes, yes, yes, a thousand times yes. As far as I’m concerned, the mismanagement of health IT should be the number one issue to be addressed in health care. It creates countless inefficiencies in our health care system. It creates all sorts of admin burden. It leads to much higher expenditures and duplicate testing. This needs to get fixed ASAP.

Item: The Ontario Medical Association (OMA) announced that nominations are open for their annual election periods. Up for grabs are four Board Director positions and many other District and Section positions.

My thoughts: Physicians in Ontario desperately need a strong OMA. The only way that can happen is if front line physicians stand up and take positions. I’ll be frank (and will offend a bunch of people) – but when I was on the Board there were too many Board Directors who clearly were in it for their own self interest and were not thinking of their colleagues. The same could be said for some other elected reps. We will get the OMA we deserve, but only if front line docs take a leading role.

We Know How to Save Family Medicine. Why Aren’t We Doing It?

I’m honoured to have Dr. Mark Linder guest blogging for me today. I first met Dr. Linder during our time advocating against Dr. Eric Hoskins unilateral cuts to health care. He’s exceptionally well spoken and articulate . He’s a former ER doctor and now full time family physician and clinic owner. His other claim to fame is that got fired from the Kaplan MCAT teaching course after one session – which apparently was a first.

I just wrote this in a flurry this morning. I see stupider and stupider proposals from the government and from newspaper editorials. I see our new grads learn from their teachers that they need to stay away from this job. I then see the domino effect this has on recruitment, job satisfaction and reinforced by absurd government initiatives to save the system. I watch the OMA get pulled in every direction to try and please everyone. So apologies in advance -this is just my take really-and mostly to get it off my chest-not that it will lead anywhere. So thanks for reading.

The Family Health Organization (FHO) is what saves family medicine. It has done it before and it can do it again.

In 2006 something unprecedented happened. It hasn’t happened before or since. And perhaps we didn’t quite appreciate how unique it was. The provincial Liberal government, under Dalton McGuinty and Health Minister George Smitherman, introduced an upgraded payment model for Family Medicine. It built on the existing capitation based Family Health Network (FHN) model to enhance it.

What was so unique about this? It stands out as one of the only times a government has thought beyond their 4 year term to the ultimate health of their population as well as their economy down the road when they may no longer be in power. Sure, it was going to make them look good if everyone got a family doctor out of it-but it was a big expensive risk, a risk based on an assumption that family medicine was critical to the system, AND that practitioners need to be paid fairly for their work if they wish to retain these doctors in the future. A different time to be sure!

It worked. Look at the stats from 2008 to 2018. Look at how many Family Doctors gladly embraced the new system. Look how the number of orphaned patients dropped.

The system had flaws. I mean this was the second iteration of what was described as an experiment. The “outside use” enforcement rule made little sense in most cases. The calculation of capitation payments wasn’t always a fair representation of how much work it took to look after the patient in front of you. Certain “in the basket” fees were bizarre and should never have been part of the package. Doctors were actually more incentivized to send people to the ER over a walk in clinic!!! But all in all, it was a great innovation, a great idea, and saved family medicine. It also, no doubt saved the province millions in treatment dollars and ER visits as family doctors made themselves available to look after patients.

And then, In 2015 Kathleen Wynne and Eric Hoskins, the health minister at the time, effectively shut down enrollment in FHOs And that was the beginning of the end. I presume they just wanted to control the immediate budget – paying for family medicine up front meant huge savings down the road. But it resulted in a pretty big chunk of budget going out the door NOW. And the Wynne liberals didn’t have a health care crisis, didn’t heed the warnings that we as physicians laid out pretty starkly at the time, and decided, nah, we’ll just “pause” the experiment.

Which they did. And the fall out was obvious. As a clinic owner and a family doctor, I had a front row seat. The residents and new grads had all been trained in the new system, and now were unable to access it. If they wanted to work, they’d be taking a tremendous risk setting up a clinic in a Fee For Service environment using a Schedule of Benefits that had failed to keep up with inflation for 20 years. They were screwed. The aging Family Doctor population continued to retire at a predictable rate, and the aging population continued to get more desperate to find doctors with increasing difficulty.

By the time the FHO’s opened up again in 2021, it barely mattered–The reputation of family medicine among new grads had been thrashed for 6 years.
With the new rules, new grads would have to gather 6 like-minded individuals (instead of just 3 like in the old days), or find a bigger FHO that was already established and could fit them in. Not so easy. Opening up your own shop had become increasingly more expensive with post pandemic inflation, so the debt would be crippling just to get started if you wanted your own clinic. And these are graduates who already had a huge amount of debt coming out of school.

Couple this with the insane increase in administrative burden as we become more and more efficient at having hospitals and labs forward us copies of paperwork. In theory, amazing, in practice hugely burdensome, time consuming and unpaid. Arguably, if the FHO rates had increased at the level of inflation, there’d be no complaints about this additional work. But the FHO rates had more or less remained static relative to the cost of doing business. Still better than FFS, still paid a lot less than the actual market value of doing the job as proven by the lack of uptake that continues today.

The thing is: The FHO is still the answer. It absolutely needs some significant tweaks. The rates need to go up. The outside use concept needs to go. Minimum size and shared EMR requirement needs to be softened so that smaller groups can join together in nearby geographic areas. Some sort of separate funding will be essential to help clinic owners to keep up with inflation. But it still achieves by far the best mix of physician autonomy, clinic management, and long term government savings. And it’s evidence-based! We have a recent history we can look back on to demonstrate efficacy!

Other solutions, such as having lesser-trained individuals diagnosing and managing patients give the appearance of short term gains at a huge future cost as more referrals to specialists are made and more referrals to the ER are made. Another concept of having government run all clinics is clearly so expensive as to be dead at the gates-Doctors currently pay for rent, administration and their own retirements out of their incomes. It’s not great for us, but it’s a heck of a lot cheaper for the taxpayer to do it that way, and simply pay the doctors more.

I recognize that my FFS colleagues are not helped at all by an enhancement and advocacy for the FHO approach. And I’m sorry. I obviously think there’s a lot of work that could be done to improve FFS rules and individual payments. No doubt.

But we actually have the evidence that the FHO saved family medicine when it was introduced. It was stunningly effective, and if nursed back to health, will absolutely work again.

Sunday Snippets – Oct. 27, 2024

I was away last week but I’m back with another in a weekly series of brief snippets of health care stories that bemused, intrigued and otherwise beguiled me over the past week along with my random thoughts on the matter.

Item: There was significant growth in the number of physicians in Alberta in the third quarter.

My Thoughts: Alberta is kind of a funny province. There are some very strange goings on with their health care policy. But it can’t be denied that despite all of that, if you provide incentives to attract younger physicians it will help. Having said that, it can all be easily undone if they don’t get on with it and implement the compensation for family physicians they promised, and for some reason appears to be delayed.

Item: The province of Nova Scotia has launched a physicians retirement fund initiative, helping physicians to retire well.

My Thoughts: What’s that you say? You mean ensuring that physicians have peace of mind about their retirement might actually help recruit (gasp!) and even retain (double gasp!!) physicians? Who would have thunk it?? In all seriousness, given the way the Federal Liberal government of our effete Prime Minister really screwed physicians with the recent tax law changes – this is a necessary move and I hope will get copied by all provinces. It really will help improve morale and reduce some of the burnout.

Item: John Richards and Tingting Zhang, from the CD Howe Institute wrote an op-ed in the Financial Post encouraging more use of nurse practitioners since they can “do almost everything an MD can”.

My Thoughts: El Toro Poo Poo. (This is a PG rated blog so that’s all I could get away with). I work with Nurse Practitioners and I have seen them help patients and I firmly believe they have a role in health care. But that role is not to replace physicians. The studies that show they can “do almost everything” are done based on what scope of practice suggests they can do. The blunt reality is nurse practitioners drive up costs and worsen care if used in settings as these characters suggest. The studies that show that NPs are cheaper ONLY look at the actual income an NP gets and compare it to a physicians income, as opposed to looking at the work that is actually done/number of patients seen/and number of tests ordered. The FP article isn’t even fit to be used for toilet paper.

Item: The crisis in Home Care supplies, first reported by Avis Favaro on X (formerly Twitter) continues. Home care nurses are reporting heartbreaking stories of patients buying their own supplies on Amazon since home care couldn’t provide them. Dr. Drew Moore and Dr. Hal Berman should be lauded for going public with their concerns. (I’ve met both of them and they are both mensches).

My Thoughts: I’m old. I’ve seen a lot of government screw ups in my time, especially in health care. But I have yet to see bureaucrats who screw up be truly held accountable and fired. Ever. They just get shuffled off to some other department. It it too much to ask that if someone makes a mistake at their job (and this is a BIG one) they get held accountable?

Item: Quebec is attacking family doctors for some reason. First they suggested they would link people to non-family physicians for care and even remove patients who were “healthy” from their own family physicians. Then they presented erroneous data suggesting that family doctors basically don’t work hard enough.

My Thoughts: There are 9 other provinces and 3 territories that would love to have these doctors.

Item: Penn State Medical Residents unionized, went on strike and got significant benefits (despite being driven off the hospital grounds by hospital security!)

My thoughts: Unionization of physicians is going to happen eventually. Whether through the long gestating Charter Challenge (yes my Ontario peeps – it is still working its way through the courts) or some other mechanism. The younger physicians clearly seem to want this model of representation and at some point in the not too distance future, physicians will be unionized.

Item: The Ontario government announced plans to effectively bar foreign students from attending medical school in Ontario.

My thoughts: My thanks to Am640 News for interviewing me on the topic, and my thoughts on this can be heard below. (This short version – this is populist rhetoric that will do nothing to help with the health care crisis):

Ontario Government to Family Doctors: The Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves

That we have a family medicine crisis in Ontario is indisputable. That the numbers of family doctors leaving comprehensive care family medicine continues to rise and is expected to leave over 4 million people without a family doctor in the next couple of years is irrefutable. That the need to recruit and retain comprehensive care family doctors has never been more urgent especially as competition from provinces like British Columbia, Manitoba and others increases is unquestionable.

All of this is self evident to anybody following health care.

People lined up in Kingston desperately hoping to get a family doctor when a new clinic opened (image first put out by the CBC)

Except of course, the Ontario Government, and their Ministry of Health Bureaucrats. As far as they are concerned, now is actually the perfect time to attack family doctors. Because, you know, the way to improve burnout, morale and encourage them to take on new patients is to ambush people who are already under siege with overwhelming workloads.

Here’s what happened. About 6,000 family doctors in Ontario practice under what is called a Family Health Organization (FHO) model. Think of it as a base salary plus performance bonuses. As part of working in that model, the family doctors have to sign a contract agreeing to deliver a basket of services, including, a certain amount of after hours care.

Because we have so many rural areas in Ontario, where family doctors do a whole bunch of other work (emergency department, hospital on call, palliative care, long term care on call and more), there is a provision in the contract that says if you have X number of family doctors doing this kind of work already, then the amount of after hours care you provide as a FHO can be reduced. There’s a somewhat complicated formula but that doesn’t really matter – it’s the principle that counts. Essentially, if you are already doing after hours work – then you are not asked to do more after hours work.

Unless of course you are a Ministry of Health bureaucrat, taking the guidance of your bellicose negotiations team that said there was “no concern” about a shortage of family physicians. This allows you licence to use a stick against family physicians.

Then, you send letters to 75 FHOs telling them they are not meeting the terms of their contract, based on made up metrics. The letters (I’ve seen a few of them) all allege that the doctors in the FHOs are not living up to the terms of their contract.

Let’s be 100% clear on this. If a physician signs a contract as part of a FHO, they should hold up their end of the bargain. You should read the contract, go in with your eyes open, and make sure you are capable of meeting all of the terms that you agreed to.

BUT.

It appears what the Ministry is arbitrarily and unilaterally determining how to decide if a physician is meeting the terms. For example, one FHO letter I saw suggested that that FHO was not performing as well as its “peers” and was therefore targeted. Two things though. First the Ministry unilaterally decided who the peers were. Second, performing up to the standards of your peers was not part of the original contract.

Another letter I saw alleged that the doctors who do call for their hospital or their nursing home, don’t qualify because……they don’t bill enough for going into the hospital. The ministry unilaterally decided that in order to claim after hours work, you couldn’t just be on call, but you had to keep going into the hospital when on call, a certain number of times (this number was never up for discussion before).

I’ll use myself as an example. Last Wednesday I was on call for my hospital. I got three calls (one at 4:00 am!) and managed all the patients over the phones. I DID perform the task I agreed to (being on call). But the bungling bureaucrats won’t acknowledge that. They want me go to the hospital (even if I can handle it over the phone) and then bill OHIP for the service (which would drive UP the cost!!) to be recognized – a decision they seemingly made on their own, without consultation.

My two loyal fans and one non-fan regular reader know that I’ve long maintained that Star Trek is a far better franchise than Star Wars. But in this case, I will concede the Ministry’s actions are most appropriately compared to this fellow:

Normally when a government changes the terms of an agreement unilaterally, one would expect the Ontario Medical Association to step in and advocate for their members. However, the response from the OMA, in a letter sent to all its members was, frankly, pathetic. The letter basically told doctors to “notify the Ministry” about the circumstances around your group. Try to reason with Darth Vader as it was. No dedicated email or legal team staff member either. Just contact the general help email.

I guess specialists who had expressed concerns on Social Media about too many family doctors on the OMA Board have nothing to worry about. Clearly the OMA, between allowing the across the board increases to the arbitration award this year and not dedicating resources to tackle this issue cares nothing about family medicine. (They talk a great game on social media, but it’s the actions that count).

I imagine the issue will eventually sort itself out after many rancorous meetings and back and forth – all of which will take up physicians time and prevent them from doing minor and inconsequential things like, say, seeing patients. The Ministry will continue to claim that we have more family doctors than ever before – but let’s face it, if they keep behaving like this, those doctors won’t practice comprehensive care medicine. It just seems so ridiculous, and indicative of a Ministry that truly doesn’t understand or value family medicine.

And that should frighten the general public more than the Death Star ever did. (Drat, made ANOTHER Star Wars reference).